Slavers who displayed a “remarkable absence of humanity” in failing to apologise to the woman they held captive for eight years are about to be sentenced for their crimes.
Kumuthini and Kandasamy Kannan each face 25 years in prison after being convicted of holding a vulnerable Tamil woman as a slave in their Mount Waverley home between 2007 and 2015.
Despite desperate pleas to be allowed to return to her family in southern India, the woman was forced to work up to 23 hours a day caring for the couple’s children, cooking, cleaning and doing chores.
She had tea and curries thrown at her, was beaten with a frozen chicken and when her son-in-law asked the Kannans to let her return home they responded “f*** you”.
The woman, who cannot be identified, was a hard worker who tolerated being at their beck and call.
In exchange she was paid what amounted to $3.36 per day.
The woman, in her 60s, was rushed to hospital by ambulance in July 2015 after collapsing.
She was malnourished, suffering untreated medical conditions including sepsis and diabetes, and was in a “dreadful” state.
There was a wholesale neglect of her health, Justice John Champion said in a pre-sentence hearing.
“No one has expressed any sense of regret or sorrow. It’s a fairly remarkable absence of humanity,” he said.
He will sentence the Kannans on Wednesday.
Kandasamy Kannan’s “reluctance” to apologise came from concerns an expression of regret might stand as an admission and potentially impact an appeal, his barrister John Kelly SC said.
While Kumuthini Kannan’s barrister Gideon Boas said his client had expressed sorrow to him for the woman’s condition, she did not accept responsibility for causing it.
She will appear by videolink from prison at Wednesday’s sentencing hearing, while her husband – who is on bail – will appear in person.
Justice Champion has expressed extreme anger at repeated failures by the couple and their defence teams to not arrange appropriate care for their three vulnerable children.
In April he accused the couple of putting a gun to the court’s head by failing to organise care, forcing him to extend their bail.
Last month he allowed Kandasamy Kannan to remain on bail as a compromise, while berating the couple’s barristers.
“I can’t express my displeasure strongly enough that this hasn’t been remedied yet. I am extremely angry,” he said.